Music Notes

For the Love of a Wanton Woman

TO PUBLISH INCONVENIENT NEWS WE RELY ON DONATIONS Please contact Michael Walsh for easy transfer details

In a letter dated October 1866, French composer Georges Bizet (1838 – 1875) went straight to the point of opera: ‘As a musician, I tell you that if you were to suppress adultery, fanaticism, crime, evil, the supernatural, there would no longer be the means for writing one note.’

The opera prodigy and gifted pianist sprinkled far more of the human experience into his much-loved opera. Carmen is arguably still the world’s most popular opera one hundred and forty-seven years after his death when the French composer was just thirty-six years of age.

As a staged spectacular it was an opera that pioneered the grittiness of real-life characters and events. From Carmen flowed a new genre of opera which set the scene for Mascagni’s Cavalleria Rusticana, Leoncavallo’s Pagliacci, and Puccini’s La Boheme. The new genre were forerunners to great movie dramas for they depicted real-life warts and all.

Carmen is the story of an enchantingly beautiful coquettish factory worker of questionable morality. By feminine guile, she uses, abuses and seduces her way through a rich tapestry of soldiers, gipsies, thieves and smugglers.

Her flirtatiousness finally brings the seductress to a sticky end at the point of a dagger wielded by her jealous soldier lover. The finale of this nail-biting drama takes place outside the arena as her bullfighter lover triumphs over his bovine adversary.

George Bizet the musician was a handsome bearded man not unlike his contemporary Peter Tchaikovsky. This French composer of Spain’s most celebrated musical masterpiece delighted in his own compositions but was bemused when his orchestrations never won hearts and minds. Yet strangely, he failed to fully appreciate Carmen his – well, the world’s favourite opera that was to earn considerable acclaim and was to make him a household name throughout the world.

It is a mystery how the young Bizet could consider Carmen a flop. From the start, he had been paid the considerable sum of 25,000 francs and awarded the Chevalier of the legion d’honneur for the composition.

This risqué opera received an impressive 37 performances. Had he lived just another three months he would have seen Carmen triumph beyond his wildest imagination and within three years the steamy opera was playing to packed houses throughout the world.

‘Ah music!’ he is quoted as saying: ‘What a beautiful art but what a wretched profession.’

Bizet was hardly a one opera wonder though it cannot be denied that Carmen was more successful than his lesser-known opera, The Pearl Fishers. Its celebrated duet Les pêcheurs de perles (In the Depths of the Temple) on a number of occasions has been voted by radio listeners as their all-time favourite piece of classical music. For sheer musical whimsy Bizet’s music set to the Alphonse Daudet’s play L’Arlésienne takes some beating.

This self-effacing composer joined the echelon of history’s greatest composers from quite an early age. Before his eighteenth birthday, he had composed his first symphony, which is said to rival anything composed by Mozart or Mendelssohn when they were teenagers too.


He had also won a competition sponsored by the theatre impresario Jacques Offenbach and was later awarded the coveted Prix de Rome. Gustav Mahler, one of the greatest composers of all time, considered George Bizet’s Djamileh a masterpiece.

Such was the man who on his death bed considered himself to be a failure. At the last count, there have been fourteen screen versions of Carmen not to mention the famous Hammerstein stage adaptation Carmen Jones (1945). One can only wonder what this remarkable composer might consider success. 


Donate: It is the generosity of our supporters and members that makes our vital work possible. As the storm clouds of crisis and the pain of injustice and persecution loom over our people, the potential and importance of our work grows day-by-day. There is no George Soros figure out there for nationalists, so we can only do what good people like you help us to do. Thank you for your faith and your generous commitment: contact Michael

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s